Stones in water is a 1997 work of young adult fiction by donna jo napoli. When roberto sneaks off to see a movie in his italian village, he has no idea that life as he knows it is over. However, its important to distinguish between the work of a professional artist and a hobbyist. Stones in water book by donna jo napoli thriftbooks. Stones in water is a fast read, and for the most part it was excellent. The persistent character of roberto shows how giving up is not a choice in life or death situations. Stones in waterhistorical fiction project by chelsea olerich. It takes place in the early 1940s, during world war ii, when nazi rule and soldiers were present in many european countries. Its different than most holocaust stories because it is set in italy, which i think is almost ignored at this point in history. Then roberto starts to walk towards the woods expecting to get shot and he doesnt so then he starts his journey to escape. Stones in water donna jo napoli published in 1997 by scholastic inc.
Abducted by nazis from a movie house near his home in venice, roberto finds himself a slave laborer in german work camps, until he escapes in the frozen ukraine and struggles to return home. The book starts in italy where memo, a younger boy would like to bring roberto to an american western film. Stones in water stones in water donna jo napoli, author, s. Roberto s quiet life as a gondoliers son ends abruptly the day he sneaks off to see a movie with his older brother and two friends, memo and. Stones in water series by donna jo napoli goodreads.
For example, sergio and roberto are brothers and their family does not like jews. Roberto, a venetian boy who is about to graduate from middle school, is so eager to attend a rare american movie that he makes a worrisome bargain with a boy who is always in trouble. Stones in water by donna jo napoli when roberto sneaks off to see a movie in his small itialian village he has no idea that life as heknows it is over. The book shows the struggles between the two boys and what life was like being taken. In stones in water, what is an example of the conflict man vs.
He is an italian boy going to see a movie with his friends when german soldiers rush the theater. Nick buice part 2 comparative response author information similarities. This is a book trailer i did on my favorite book stone in water. I think ages 1014 would relate the most easily to stones in water. Stones in water was published in 1997 and is a young adult fiction set during world war ll. Stones in water is a 1997 young adult novel written by donna jo napoli. One strategy roberto has come up with his own plan to put stones in his pocket. But they both move on and they go somewhere else unknown words. On top of this small sin, he attends the movie with a jewish boy, samuele, an unwise idea when. As i drew farther into this actionpacked book, i started to feel for roberto as he journeyed through hard times.
A book trailer made by teens in tucson, az for the pima public library. When roberto sneaks off to see a movie in his italian village, german soldiers raid the theater and pack them onto a train bound for a work camp during world war ii. Roberto twelve or thirteen, his older brother sergio, and his two friends memo and samuele are just planning to catch a movie in venice, walking there from their small town outside of venice. Librarything is a cataloging and social networking site for booklovers. Title of a book, article or other published item this will display. Donna jo napoli after being taken by german soldiers from a local movie theater along with other italian boys including his jewish friend, roberto is forced to work in germany, escapes into the ukrainian winter. In the last few years the rock painting art has achieved a great success around the world and many fans of this fascinating technique have decided to submit their works online and sell them through shopping channels. Stones in water starts out with an italian boy named roberto, his freind memo, his brother sergio, and his other friend samuel, who is jewish, going to a movie. Their struggle to survive, hide the jewish boys nationality, and the defeat of one and escape of another is chronicled. The book starts in italy where memo, a younger boy would like to bring roberto. Roberto and his friends go to see a movie, and their lives are forever changed when german soldiers raid the theater and kidnap all of the boys.
German soldiers raid the theater, round up the boys in the audience, and pack them onto a train. Roberto s brother, a teen too young to be in the army but old enough to drill each sunday, and memo, the quickwitted friend. Immediately download the stones in water summary, chapterbychapter analysis, book notes, essays, quotes, character descriptions, lesson plans, and more everything you need for studying or teaching stones in water. The main character, roberto is a catholic boy who has jewish friend, samuele. Donna jo napoli life is hard for roberto and samuele in the nazi forced labour camp but soon it becomes impossible the only hope for roberto is escape, but can he survive the brutal winter and find his way home.
Roberto is forced to work in germany, escapes into the ukrainian winter, before desperately trying to make his way back home to venice. But when he escapes he joins the italian resistance to try to get back to venice. Jun 30, 1997 stones in water was published in 1997 and is a young adult fiction set during world war ll. Apr 21, 2015 with that introduction, i present stones in water. One day a soldier named arbeiter stops and asks about roberto s stones. One difference in the two stories, is that in the masque of the red death, death seeks out the evil prince prospero, where as. This story is about roberto struggling for his life and how people dealt with a terrible war. They are taken to nazi work camps where they are pushed into hard labor and grueling work. Roberto and samueleenzo are the central figures in napolis extraordinary novel, which though written for young. Samuele is a little more special because he is jewish. Stones in water begins with a boy named roberto and his friends as well as his brother head to the movies. Jul 23, 2008 i have questions about the book stones in the water okay, so i read the book and it was really good, but i dont seem to understand what the two little jewish girls have to do with the story.
They became caught up in the war and were used as forced labor for the nazis at various work camps deep within german territory. It is filled with history, action, and survival skills. Both the girls and roberto need to be more clever so they dont get caught. Stones in water how did roberto make a difference in the world in the book stones in water. Jun 28, 2012 stones in water is a fast read, and for the most part it was excellent. Though roberto feels that he knows something about the war, he discovers many other things he knew nothing about. Stones in water and millions of other books are available for instant access. She is the chairperson of the linguistics department at swarthmore college. Stones in water is a 1997 youngadult novel by donna jo napoli about a pair of young boys in venice who are captured by nazis and sent to a work camp a good example of the man vs.
Stones in water is a book by donna jo napoli about a boy named roberto. I know they gave roberto the stone that he kept with him but what does the stone symbolize. They are roberto, sergio, memo, and samuele and they are all italian. I have 25 years proven track record as rock painter and i. Sep 26, 2008 roberto had a stone as a gift from a jewish girl who was imprisoned at a holding camp. I think he will be captured by the german soldiers. My favorite part is when roberto got shot in the arm. This study guide consists of approximately 15 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of stones in water. Oct 09, 2012 this is a book trailer i did on my favorite book stone in water.
A boy named roberto and his jewish friend samuele were rounded up like cattle by german soldiers and put on a train, leading them to a place of horror. Unfortunately one of the first things that happens to him is he gets captured by the germans. Roberto, a gondoliers son, and his best friend samuele are captured one day by german soldiers in a movie theater. Roberto had a stone as a gift from a jewish girl who was imprisoned at a holding camp. About stones in water when roberto sneaks off to see a movie in his italian village, he has no idea that life as he knows it is over. Roberto and all the others were taken and forced to work in german boot camps. I also recommend it to more mature children because some of the content is a bit awkward. Stones in water is a novel written by donna jo napoli.
They go into town to see a western movie, but german soldiers come in and take all of them to a german work camp. Apr 21, 2008 now roberto has been feeding the 2 girls for more than a week. This book appeals greatly to historical fiction readers, but can suit many other book preferences. Napolis stones in water won the golden kite award in 1997. And indeed, a sequel was written, fire in the hills, continuing roberto s story. After a terrifying journey, roberto and his best friend samuele find themselves in a. Stones in water topics for discussion donna jo napoli this study guide consists of approximately 15 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of stones in water. Fire in the hills is the second book in the stones in water series.
Donna jo napoli is the author of crazy jack, the magic circle, stones in water, and many other books. I really like this book and i want to read a lot more books just like stones in water. Well, it takes place in world war 2 when people didnt like jews. She has written many young adult novels including the wager in. After a terrifying journey, roberto and his best friend samuele find themselves in a brutal work camp, where food is scarce and horror is everywhere. Hand painted rocks gallery rock painting art by roberto. Some readers seem to feel that the end of the book didnt have a satisfactory conclusion, but i liked it. Stones in water is a 1997 youngadult novel by donna jo napoli about a pair of young boys in venice who are captured by nazis and sent to a work camp a. Napoli has also won a bulletin blue ribbon, school library journal best book of the year, and a publishers weekly choice of the years best books for her novel zel. At first he thinks nothing of it because italy and germany are allies, until they load him on a train and send him to a work camp. In stones in water, what is an example of the conflict man. He does this so it looks like he has rocks in his pocket instead of food. The reason why stones in water stands out it is because its not entirely about a jewish person.
Before i read the book, i thought it was going to be about a boy just throwing stones in the water, but i was wrong. She has written many young adult novels including the wager in 2010. Chapter 611 now roberto has been feeding the 2 girls for more than a week. Based loosely on a real account of children in concentration camps during world war ii, it concerns the strife of four boys from italy, memo, sergio, roberto, and samuele, who are sent to work in one of the camps. Stones in water by donna jo napoli, paperback barnes.
Summarize in section two of stones in water roberto has lost his best friend due to when samuel enzo was fighting off the thefts when they were trying to steal their boots. Stones in waterhistorical fiction project by chelsea. While there, german soldiers come and cart the boys there off to a camp. I would give this book a 3 out of 5 as it was entertaining but not my type of book. It is set during world war ii and tells the story of two italian boys, one of whom is jewish, who are sent to a work camp. Roberto and his friends go to see a movie, and their lives are forever. Explore our collection of motivational and famous quotes by authors you know and love. A historical fiction project based off of the book stones in water by donna jo napoli. Stones in water is a 1997 youngadult novel by donna jo napoli about a pair of young boys in venice who are captured by nazis and sent to a work camp. Roberto and his best friend, samuele, vow to stick together. Hinting at a sequel, i felt that roberto has more in store for him than just going home.
74 599 529 966 583 1579 298 519 1231 1325 923 694 814 1157 736 473 657 268 1359 1582 743 891 1389 694 1473 736 1261 842 611 940 894 165 297 867 1212